Wednesday, January 28, 2015

Where do we go from here?

There is nothing like reflecting on the entire span of our planet's history to get some perspective on where we, as a species and civilization, are today. The study of this immense period of time, and not merely the relatively brief history of mankind, is amongst the most insightful and beneficial parts of any person's education. Too many of us are only interested or preoccupied with the recent history of humanity, for example from the beginning of the industrial revolution and the birth of modern nation states. Undeniably, the geopolitics of today have been predominantly shaped by the events of the previous centuries, especially since the first World War. Analyzing this period is perhaps useful for making short term general predictions of the positioning of each country viz-a-vi one another in the next few years, but to look further ahead at where we as a global society is headed we need to dig a little deeper. I will come back to the 20th century again, if only to highlight the extremely rapid changes wrought by our species on Earth in a relatively short span of time. To really understand where we've come from, it is useful to look back much further, beyond the age of civilizations, past the paleolithic even, when we lived as hunter-gatherers for perhaps a hundred thousand years before agriculture was invented. I am speaking of geological epochs, the time scale at which the evolution of life takes place i.e. millions of years.

Source: http://nautil.us/issue/17/big-bangs/the-greatest-animal-war

The Earth has a history of some 4.5 billion years, but life really only took off with the Cambrian explosion some 550 million years ago when large bodied multicellular organisms rapidly colonized first the oceans, then the land. This means for almost 90% of its existence our planet was a barren, lifeless rock (if we exclude simple single celled life). Despite the conditions being suitable for life to arise, like the planet being in a sweet spot in terms of distance from the sun, for water to remain in liquid form, for instance, for almost four billion years there was nothing substantial beyond archaic bacteria-like life forms. To keep the story short, the onset of complex life led to the spread of ever larger and more complex biota, culminating in the era of dinosaurs, before they were unceremoniously wiped out by an asteroid strike from space. One wonders if that had not happened what would be the state of life on Earth today, and if intelligent, sentient beings like ourselves would still have eventually evolved. Perhaps if that evolutionary trajectory had not been disrupted it could have brought forward sentient life by millions of years, instead of resetting the clock back to zero but allowing mammalian life to fill the vacuum and inherit the Earth. But I digress!

In any case, it took another 63 million years give or take, for our planet to produce walking apes that would eventually lead to hominids and us, "only" around a million years ago. We were rather insignificant as a species for the majority of that time, just another large bodied mammal trying to make a living from the land, in competition with the suite of various mega-fauna of the time like cave lions, dire wolves and mammoths to name just three. With the discovery of fire and refinement of tool use humans dispersed out of Africa and gradually spread out worldwide to every continent. Still, our numbers remained small and impact on the environment was localized and negligible, if we conveniently overlook the extinction of mega-fauna that have been attributed to our competitive edge.

Things began to pick up with the dawn of farming around ten thousand years ago, which allowed our population to rise rapidly as settlements expanded and technological progress gathered pace. However, for thousands of years of civilization, we could only rely on the energy from ourselves, other creatures, the sun, wind, and living plants to do our bidding. It was only with the unlocking of energy from fossil fuels, accumulated underground since the beginning of life on Earth (i.e. hundreds of millions of years worth) that we really took off, quite literally. One has only to look at charts of world population, GDP and energy use to see the exponential growth of our species, particularly in the last century and more so post-WW2. In 1900 there were about 1.6 billion people, we are at seven billion today, all in a mere hundred years. Economic and industrial output growth are even more rapid, driven by associated massive inputs of material and energy resources. Which brings me to the point of this essay - that it is simply impossible for our current path of expansion to last much longer.


Exponential growth of any sort has the effect of compressing time, as the underlying subject increases in a geometric progression. Each doubling of number requires a shorter period as the base expands. Looking back at the history of life on Earth and the sheer stretch of deep time that has passed, one can be fooled into thinking there is ample time still for something to happen, perhaps the discovery of a new energy source, or the ability to colonize other planets that will once again push those annoying physical resource limits away from their current constraints on carrying capacity. But the enemy of exponential growth is against us in this fight. We just do not have another thousand or even a few hundred years to figure a way out of the limits of a finite Earth. I venture that in all likelihood we don't even have another hundred years. Before this century ends, i.e. within our children's lifetime, things would have to come to a head. This is no mere hysteria on my part without substantiation or deliberate, rational analysis. In all but a few of the multiple scenarios generated by a sophisticated model from the authors of 'Limits to Growth'*, some sort of collapse is forecast before the end of the 21st century. To summarize their analysis, even if we were to take collective action quickly and invent practical technologies without further delay, we will inevitably come up against limits of one sort or another to further economic expansion. There has to be a sea change in mindset away from the goal of perpetual material growth if we are to avoid the inevitable downward 'adjustment' in ecological carrying capacity. Yet the majority of us blindly go about our individual lives without any seeming concern or awareness of the cliff looming ahead of humanity. We continue to strive for the next career advancement, upgrade our houses, our cars, put our kids into prestigious institutions so that they may become even more materially well-off, ad infinitum. It is truly mass insanity, truth be told, as we step on the accelerator even whilst headed for the precipice.

From a lifeless rock and empty world, to one filled to brimming with humans, but all the impact on the planet has come about within the last hundred years, a blink of an eye as they say, in the enormous span of geological time. How long will the Anthropocene (Age of Man) last? At the rate we are going it could be just another blink of an eye. Just take a look at those population and world economy charts, the way the lines on the graphs rocket almost to the vertical, and tell me if you think otherwise.

And we have lift-off!
 *Donella H. Meadows, Dennis L. Meadows, Jorgen Randers, Limits to Growth: The 30-Year Update (Chelsea Green Publishing, 2004)

New Year thoughts

Firstly, Happy New Year to everyone! May you have a great year ahead.

So 2015 is upon us! I don't know about you, but the years of the new millennium just seem to fly by so quickly. Could it be that as adults, our lives do not vary that much from year to year, compared to the many milestones one crosses from childhood to adolescence and beyond? I was sitting at a cafe in a neighborhood I grew up in, and they were playing pop music from the 1980s. It felt like I was stuck in time or back in the past, looking around at the familiar buildings and layout of the street where I have been hanging out since I was a teenager. It got me thinking of how change in general seems to have slowed down, at least from my perspective. As a kid, the 21st century held great mystique and wonder for me, watching movies like Back to the Future, Total Recall, Terminator and Star Wars. It seemed so far away back then that the possibilities were endless! Flying cars, spaceships, laser ray guns, fully intelligent robots and artificial beings, the list went on. Here we are now, well into the 21st century, and it's as if nothing much has changed, or at least the rate of technological advancement has slowed compared to the 1980s and 90s. What do we have to show for it? The internet, Facebook, twitter, instagram, whatsapp, smartphones? YAWN. It pales in comparison to the very real sense of progress I felt as first CDs, then portable mp3 players replaced walkmans, cell phones rapidly became ubiquitous and outmoded fixed line telephones, answering machines and pagers, the PC and laptop took over from giant room-sized mainframe computers, to name some examples. Where are the advances in new hardware today? The iphone? That's merely an improved cell phone that plays music and video and takes pictures! That's nothing compared to the digital revolution seen in camera technology that put professional grade SLR cameras within reach of many. If we went back even further and compared the progress made during the 1950s and 60s, when jet planes and plastics took over, or the explosion in new forms of transportation and warfare made possible by the industrial revolution of the 19th century, the disparity in revolutionary inventions really becomes apparent. Where are the wonders that would be possible with our knowledge of genetic engineering and ability to map genomes? AIDS and cancer still plague us, while hybrid beasts, super soldiers and clone armies are nowhere to be found.

You still haven't arrived, T1000.

My point in all this rambling, patient reader, is that the rate of technological progress has slowed. This, despite our population skyrocketing past 7 billion souls, making available more combined brainpower collectively than in previous times. This is worrying because the longer we take to make significant breakthroughs the more problems we face from the negative effects of growth. It is like a snowball accumulating in size as it rolls, making the need to find new resources on the one hand and deal with the waste products of our civilization on the other that much more urgent as time passes. What will we invent that will replace our dwindling fossil fuel (albeit largely oil) resources that underpin our ability to sustain the current number of people on Earth? We are truly in a race against time, and it seems to me that the previous 14 years of this century were wasted on waging wars and on financial speculation, while the world continued on its business-as-usual trajectory, consuming ever more non renewable resources and putting ever greater stresses on our one precious planet.

My hope for the new year is that we see some genuine progress toward addressing humanity's predicament, be it more agreement on what to do about climate change, new inventions that could help reduce our ecological footprint, or better yet, change in our behavior to become less consumers of material goods, with more focus on mental and spiritual well-being.

Here's toward a brighter future for us all!